"Does an excellent job of giving us both the petty feuds and the principles behind them."
—Times Literary Supplement
"It is certainly useful to have a study of an important conceptual debate that goes into the political wings so thoroughly."
—British Society for Literature and Science
"An excellent, careful account of the antiliterary, anti-Romantic perspectives of those well-known founders of academic history."
—Journal of British Studies
"Well planned, well informed and genuinely well written."
"This colorful and conflicted history of the battle between the art of history and the science of history is a welcome addition to the growing literature on nineteenth-century science and culture."
"This book deserves much credit for making light of little-known and complex debates, and for demonstrating how great a variety of methodological standpoints is hidden behind the 'Whig' political label under which most of the historians it studies have usually been grouped."
—British Journal for the History of Science
"Artfully conceived and highly readable."
—Canadian Journal of History
"Hesketh pays welcome attention to the intellectual and religious currents that shaped Victorian historians' lives and, by extension, their methods."